Tuesday, August 7, 2007

Hillary's DOMA Dilemma

Here is a response that Hillary Clinton gave in response to a question posed by Paul Hogarth of BeyondChron during her breakout session at the YearlyKos Convention:

Secondly, DOMA, I believe that DOMA served a very important purpose. I was one of the architects in the strategy against the Marriage Amendment to the constitution, and DOMA gave us a bright line to be able to hold back the votes that were building up to do what I consider to be absolutely abominable and that would be to amend the constitution to enshrine discrimination. I believe marriage should be left to the states. I support civil unions as I’ve said many times with full equality of benefits and so I think that DOMA appropriately put the responsibility in the states where it has historically belonged and I think you’re beginning to see states take action. I think it’s, I think part three of DOMA needs to be repealed because part three stands in the way of the full extension of federal benefits and I support that. So that’s the first.


She pretty much said that banning equal marriage is discrimination, which makes me wonder why she isn't better on issues of equal rights. But, that's a completely different issue.

However, if Hillary supported passage of DOMA then as a means to prevent passage of FMA, then the fact that FMA no longer stands a chance at passage should be taken into account now. Accordingly, she should take her support of repealing parts of DOMA further.

The commerce clause of the United States constitution makes it clear that each of the States shall respect the laws of other States. Accordingly, it wouldn't be a stretch for her to advocate repealing that provision of DOMA.

Recent news articles in Newsweek and the Washington Blade showcase the tremendous support that Hillary is receiving from the LGBT communities around the country.

The question remains with regard to what we are getting for our support. Very little time has been spent addressing LGBT rights during the previous Presidential debates and forums. This Thursday, Logo Network and the Human Rights Campaign will host a forum with the Democratic Presidential candidates. (Joe Biden never committed and Chris Dodd recently canceled.)

Here is a comment which doesn't make me think that any candidate will be pressed towards taking positions in support of our movement toward equal rights.

The purpose of this forum is not to provide gotcha moments, because that doesn’t serve anybody well,” said Jonathan Capehart, a gay Washington Post editorial page writer who will serve as a panelist for the forum.

But you do want to get the candidates talking about these issues in a way that’s human and not overly rehearsed.


I hope the panelists will consider pressing Hillary on this point. Accordingly, I hope Hillary will show the courage to expand her position and show the LGBT community that she is truly willing to fight for equality.

11 comments:

Jeff Autero said...

Lane I am also a blogger. I can be found at www.savethemiddleclass.com and I am also gay. I am trying to develop an internet talk show and i am looking for a co-host. Any interest? Feel free to go to my site and contact me.

Anonymous said...

Gay rights does seem to be an issue candidates want to avoid. Many in the US, including a few dems I know, seem to be unreasonably homophobic.

My opinion is that nobody is truly free if one person(s) is oppressed.

lloydletta said...

Hillary Clinton's statement about DOMA is an absolute lie. The FMA was not an issue when DOMA was introduced. Want to check the facts? Call Bob Barr - who was the chief author of DOMA. DOMA was about not forcing other states to recognise gay marriages done in a state that allowed gay marriages.

The FMA became an issue much, much later, after a number of constitutional amendments passed in various states in reaction to judicial rulings that suggested state constitutions required recognition that gays be included in the institution of marriage.

The FMA was NOT an issue when DOMA was an issue. The FMA was proposed in 2002.

Hillary Clinton should NOT be allowed to rewrite history. She should also be asked whether she agreed with the Clinton campaign's decision to advertise his support of DOMA on christian radio.

What really occurred is gay groups like HRC did NOT fight this - instead, they were focused on ENDA and Hate Crimes - and gave dems a pass on this one.

elizabeth bernot said...

Costa Rica Fishing

http://www.fishingcostaricaexperts.com/

Fishing Costa Rica

linge said...

Our English Beats By Dre UK teacher,Ms Huang,came to our school in 1970.She has been Monster Beats By Dr.Dre an English teacher for more than 30 years.She works hard Cheap Beats By Dre and has been a model teacher for many years.She is kind Beats By Dre Studio and friendly to us after class, but She is rather Beats By Dre Sale strict with us in class.She always encourages us to speak and read more English.She often says,Practice makes perfect.Monster Lady Gaga She is good at teaching and tries her best to make every lesson lively and interesting.Beats Kobe Bryant She often gives us slide shows,teaches us English songs and helps us to put on short Beats By Dre Sale UK English plays.

linge said...

Colossal GHD NZ Tones professional Exclusive edition to help GHD New Wave you quintana Dark-colored,the producer could possibly GHD Diamond be considered a alternation from the conventional method humble GHD Hair Straighteners eye-catching flavor,the utilization the whole headset important GHD IV Styler styles dark-gray,dr dre headphones visual element to GHD Straighteners NZ arrive to be sophisticated,restrained.It appears such as the whole PS500 GHD Gold Classic Styler features especially exclusive appear personal loan company which in turn,from totality,operates just like GHD New Zealand very various.

linge said...

Spring,Beats By Dre UK my hometown,green grass and flowers are in bloom.Out of the tree Beats Kobe Bryant branches,birds singing in the merry.Looking around is the Beats By Dre Sale continuous mountains,mountains and rolling hillsides in the spring,as if a domesticated hen the carpet,until the sky. Dr Dre Beats Headohones Graceful flowers blossoming in a dotted mountains,attract Beats By Dre Studio colorful butterflies,in the depths of the mountain is the Beats By Dre Sale terraced rows of shapes,by definition,is the same as the stairs Monster Lady Gaga rice,a winding path to article rice into the ever-changing shape,some like crescent,and some,like boats, Beats By Dre Sale UK some as sickle in the spring.

linge said...

Life is Gucci Outlet always exciting winter vacation in the Gucci Handbags winter vacation,I've learned a lot,seen a lot,also felt Gucci Shoes UK a great deal.However,the most so I was surprised that Gucci Watches the home change is so fast.From black and white TV to Gucci Sunglasses color TV,from phone to phone,from the small,inadequate housing Gucci Outlet Store to the tall,luxurious villas home has undergone an Gucci Boots enormous list goes on!Changes in home really fast.Previously,the family Gucci Sale UK house is very old,broken everywhere,and even some corner of the moss has grown,made a mold.Under heavy rain,the Gucci Pumps housing estate,take the ride for the next subtitle of the rain,so the house really Gucci Sale Online good live.

linge said...

Changes Lacoste Shoes in home really fast.Previously,hearing his mother Lacoste Causal Shoes say,when there is Shiji Li far from home and Lacoste Shoes UK school to school are to go on foot a long time.There is Lacoste Trainers a bike ride to school has been a very bad condition,but also Lacoste UK a long time so in the past.If to a rainy day,the ground bumps and hollows,and go Lacoste Carnaby to school,the water was splashing mud all clothes,dirty.If the Lacoste Lyndon Slip-on summer,a big back to school bags,clothing and certainly all wet,can squeeze Cheap Lacoste Sale UKwater from it.

linge said...

Three Jeremy Scott Adidas attributes can help people in their studies.Adidas Mickey Hi First,a sense of responsibility is important Adidas Jeremy Scott for building a sound character.If you aren't Adidas Women Wingsresponsible,you'll postpone your assignments or devote too little time Jeremy Scott Wings to your schoolwork.Second,in school life,Adidas JS Bones relationships between people are valuable.Friends can bring you Jeremy Scott Shop happiness and laughter.In addition,you can discuss problems and pursue knowledge with them.She is not only Jeremy Scott Wings Shoes our teacher but also our friend.We all respect and love her.Tomorrow she is going to Adidas Originals attend an important meeting,at which she will be given a medal for her Jeremy Scott Shoes advanced deeds

qinbincai123 said...

A tree’s leaves may be ever so good.So yutrew88 may its bark, so may its wood;
Cheap New Era Hats

New Era Fitted Hats

Wholesale Cheap Hats

Wholesale New Era Hats

Cheap 59fifty Hats